Independent Oversight & Assurance
Accountability means proving systems perform as required, not just as reported, and state agencies and health plans face real financial, legal and public trust consequences when they don’t.
Comagine Health® serves as a neutral third party across health IT systems, managed care programs and care management, validating findings against clinical records, contractual requirements and federal standards rather than self-reported metrics. That independence is what makes the findings something agencies and stakeholders can act on with confidence.
Core Solutions
Where this work takes shape
Independent Verification and Validation
Ensuring health IT systems are accurate, secure and built to perform.
Health IT systems carry significant operational and compliance risk if performance issues aren’t identified early. We provide independent technical testing and oversight across the system lifecycle to ensure systems perform as intended under real-world conditions.
How We Help
- Conduct technical testing to ensure performance, functionality and reliability
- Identify and mitigate risks, including security and compliance gaps
- Support eligibility system implementation, including modularity and interoperability
- Work alongside state teams and system vendors to validate progress and outcomes
Medicaid Managed Care External Quality Review (EQRO)
Going beyond compliance to drive real plan performance.
As one of a small number of qualified EQROs nationally, we deliver CMS-compliant, independent reviews of Medicaid and CHIP managed care programs, backed by multiple active state contracts and over 25 years of experience. We go beyond compliance and documentation, delivering the analytic depth, health equity insight and stakeholder-ready reporting that actually moves plan performance.
“The attention to detail and open lines of communication are unmatched and much appreciated.”
— MO HealthNet, Client Survey
How We Help
- Conduct mandatory EQR activities, including compliance reviews and validation of Performance Improvement Projects, Performance Measures and Provider Networks Adequacy
- Oversight for HEDIS® audits and CAHPS surveys
- Validate encounter data, network adequacy and care management performance
- Deliver focused studies across behavioral health, oral health, care and disease management, and fraud, waste and abuse
- Administer secret shopper surveys, two years ahead of anticipated federal requirements, paired with interactive dashboard reporting
- Produce consumer-facing health plan report cards, enrollee-oriented quality reporting and performance comparisons by region, plan and other characteristics
- Design, assess and support value-based purchasing initiatives
Prior Authorization and Care Management Audits
Independent evaluation when stakes are highest.
New federal prior authorization requirements now mandate faster decisions, denial rationale and public reporting of metrics, and when something goes wrong inside a managed care plan, states are on the hook. Most states don’t have the internal capacity to find out what’s actually happening. That’s where we come in.
We go beyond policy reviews and claims data. Our clinical team reviews actual records to assess whether plan decisions align with contractual and federal requirements, with an explicit equity lens across populations and geographies.
How We Help
- Audit MCO prior authorization policies, procedures and decisions through contractual and clinical record review
- Review appeals processes and outcomes to identify patterns, gaps and equity concerns
- Evaluate whether care management and disease management programs are operating as required and delivering results for members
- Conduct focus studies into specific populations, services or plan behaviors when data signals a problem
- Integrate administrative data, clinical records and stakeholder findings to surface what data alone misses
Selected Work
Recent engagements
Helping Missouri hold Medicaid managed care accountable
As Missouri weighs extending its Medicaid managed care contracts through fiscal year 2028 amid its tightest budget years in a decade, the question of whether private insurers deliver enough value to justify the cost is under public debate. Comagine provides independent evaluation of Missouri’s Medicaid managed care plans, verifying that the roughly one million Missourians enrolled receive accessible, timely and quality care and giving the state objective evidence to hold insurers accountable as budget pressure mounts.
How we work
Neutral convener
Trusted by agencies, providers and communities
Data-informed partner
Using evidence to guide decisions and identify patterns
Community-rooted collaborator
Grounded in local context and relationships
Clinically rigorous
Deep experience serving high-need populations
Scalable and adaptable
Able to support programs across settings and states
independent oversight is most credible when paired with the broader capabilities that support it
This work often connects with
Let's go beyond compliance.
Looking for independent, clinically grounded oversight that holds up to scrutiny?